It's a heavy, quality jacket that's given me another reason to look forward to the colder season. 4/5 since: A) It came with a pretty visible defect (see picture), but I've cut away the messy bit and it looks just about fine besides the discolouration. B) Getting the buttons out of the eyelets wrecked my thumbs for a few good hours. Never buttoning this thing up. Never. Ow.